DTC1066: Unwell Brand Breakdown

Good morning,

Here’s what you’ll find in today’s DTC:

1️⃣ Learn how Unwell can improve their Meta Ads by leading with value-driven benefits and setting expectations.

You’re reading this newsletter along with new subscribers from: El & Rose, Bone & Biscuit, and Yaffle & Bosk. 👋

‍🧐 When Did the Plan Stop Being the Plan?

It’s not when your marketing plan fails. It’s earlier.

Performance dips slightly. A channel softens. Costs creep up just enough to make you uneasy… and the team makes a “temporary” adjustment.

Then another. Then another...

Nothing feels dramatic, but over time the plan starts to lose its shape. What began as a clear direction turns into decisions reacting to whatever just happened.

We surveyed 540+ DTC operators and broke down the results with Keen and saw this pattern everywhere:

• 70%+ review performance at least weekly
• Nearly 70% only trust forecasts 3–6 months out
• 41% say execution is where plans break

Individually, those look like strengths. Together, they create a system where plans don’t get executed; they get reshaped.

‍🪫 The Importance of Leading With Clarity and Consistency

Unwell is a wellness beverage brand launched by Alex Cooper, podcast host of Call Her Daddy.

Positioned as a hydration drink “designed by women, for women,” the brand features electrolyte-infused beverages with added B vitamins and functional ingredients.

While still early in its lifecycle, Unwell has already secured major marketing partnerships (including a $3 million deal with the National Women’s Soccer League as their official hydration partner) and is leveraging Cooper’s massive audience to drive awareness and distribution.

Pilothouse analyzed Unwell’s Meta Ads to identify what’s working and where there are opportunities to sharpen the brand’s paid ad performance.

Image Ad #1

This creative puts the product front and center.

The minimal, colorful packaging is on-trend and eye-catching, a natural fit for Unwell’s aesthetic.

The copy headline confidently communicates a range of health benefits, which helps signal that this isn’t just another energy drink.

But the benefit call-outs are not immediately clear to most consumers.

It’s easy to understand the benefits of ‘real fruit juice’ over artificial flavors, but would the average person understand that 745mg of electrolytes is an impressive number? Would they care about DV biotin?

These call-outs require the viewer to do extra mental work, which most won’t do mid-scroll.

💡 Pilothouse Tip:

✅ Make the benefits clear: Instead of focusing on 745mg of electrolytes, call out how hydrating those electrolytes are and how staying hydrated will make them feel better.

This is a more value-driven version of the benefit that has more of an impact. Tying the ingredient back to the actual benefit or value to the person is key to differentiation.

Image Ad #2

This creative does an excellent job leading with the offer. The “BUY ONE GET ONE Free” headline is bold, legible, and impossible to miss.

The product shot is clean and appetizing, and the inclusion of UPCs adds a layer of credibility.

But the post-click experience creates friction. The “Shop Now” button takes users to a lead-capture landing page rather than directly to a purchase.

And to redeem the BOGO, customers must buy in-store and submit their receipt via PayPal or Venmo.

That’s a multi-step process that the placement doesn’t set up.

There’s also a visual disconnect: the creative features the Pineapple Coconut flavor, while the landing page highlights Peach Sorbet.

This kind of inconsistency breaks trust and can cause potential buyers to disengage.

💡 Pilothouse Tips:

✅ Be clear about your offer pre-click: When a promo involves extra steps like an in-store purchase, be upfront about it in the copy.

Something like “Buy in-store, get reimbursed instantly via Venmo” turns a potential frustration into a feature.

Transparency pre-click reduces bounce rates and builds buyer confidence.

✅ Product consistency: Make sure the product shown in the creative matches the one on the landing page. Every detail of the experience should feel intentional.

Video Ad #1

This video is genuinely entertaining.

The 90s talk show concept is creative, the production value is high, and Alex Cooper’s comedic delivery, “Drinking Unwell won’t fix your relationship problems, but it’ll make you feel like you can,” is witty and on-brand.

As a piece of branded content, it shows range.

However, the format works better for organic reach than paid conversion.

On Meta, all ads are skippable, and users are conditioned to scroll past content that doesn’t feel native to the feed.

Highly stylized, long-form concepts like this tend to perform better on YouTube or as organic social posts, where viewers actively choose to engage.

💡 Pilothouse Tip:

✅  Know your platform: This creative has real potential, just in a different context. On YouTube, it could build significant brand love.

On Meta, consider a shorter, more native-feeling cut that preserves the humor but delivers value faster. Reserve the full production for social and YouTube.

Video Ad #2

This video starts off strong.

The product appears in the first five seconds, the clips are well-produced, and the creator’s lifestyle aesthetic is polished and aspirational.

But the use cases shown (heading to a workout class, getting a facial, hitting the farmer’s market) feel relaxing rather than energizing.

The drink promoted in the video is from Unwell’s energy line. Its core value proposition is fueling busy people through demanding days. The lifestyle shown doesn’t create a felt need for the product.

The most effective product ads create a problem in the viewer’s mind before offering the solution.

Right now, this creative skips straight to the product without establishing why someone would need it.

💡 Pilothouse Tip:

✅ Content should match the product benefit: Have the creator walk through a genuinely packed day (back-to-back meetings, school pickup, a late workout, etc.)

Then show Unwell as the drink that makes it all possible. That narrative arc creates both relatability and urgency, and positions the product as a practical tool, not just a lifestyle accessory.

Video Ad #3

This is a great example of creator-led content done right.

Jake Schroeder’s signature singing format is playful, memorable, and unmistakably his.

The product appears in the first 15 seconds, and he weaves in genuine use cases and benefits rather than just holding the can.

The content feels native to his audience, not like a forced sponsorship.

💡 Pilothouse Tip:

✅ Know your target audience: Reach is great, but relevance drives results. When evaluating creator partnerships, look beyond total following to audience demographics, purchase behaviors, and brand affinity.

The best creator collaborations feel effortless, but also reach people who are genuinely likely to buy.

Conclusion

In a crowded category where creator-led brands are launching constantly, Unwell has a real product edge. The creatives just need to communicate it more clearly.

The biggest opportunity across the board is sharpening the connection between what Unwell contains and what it does for the person drinking it.

When the benefits are felt (not just listed), the brand’s differentiation becomes undeniable.

‍Claude just got faster. Anthropic partners with SpaceX to increase their compute capacity and offer higher usage limits for users. Read more →

Snapchat usage declines. App activity has declined in key markets like North America and the EU while ad business remains steady. Read more →

A new bombshell has arrived. Poppi releases a Punch Pop x Love Island can ahead of the highly anticipated 8th season. Read more →

‍📥 Got a B2B Biz?

Join dozens of B2B companies finding demand-gen success through our niche community of 150k brand leaders and founders this year. Talk to our team to learn more.

Don’t forget to rate the DTC Podcast on Apple (⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️)

DTC Newsletter is written by Rebecca Knight and Frances Du. Edited by Eric Dyck.

Please note that items in this newsletter marked with * contain sponsored content.